A native of Midlothian, Virginia, Coyle has found success at every level of lacrosse she has been a part of. At Cosby High School, she was named to the All-Conference Team as a 2nd Team selection in 2015 and 2016 while being conference champions in 2016. After Cosby, Coyle moved on to UVA Wise, where she found more success. The Cavaliers went unbeaten in 2018 and were the Mountain East Conference champions and then successfully defended their title in 2019.