The Odenton, Md., native earned honorable mention All-America honors from the United States Intercollegiate Lacrosse Association as a senior in 2018 along with All-South Region, All-State and All-Old Dominion Athletic Conference accolades.

He was a key part of the Hornet midfield as a freshman during Lynchburg’s 2015 run to the NCAA Division III championship game.

McGuire was a USILA Scholar All-American in 2018 and represented Lynchburg in the Division III North-South All-Star Game. He ranks in the program’s all-time top 10 for assists in a season (32 in 2018) and in a career (85).

McGuire graduated from Lynchburg in 2018 with degrees in business administration and sport management and is currently enrolled in the university’s master’s of business administration program.