Wagner was a standout defender for the UIndy program, one that claimed the 2018 and 2019 Great Lakes Intercollegiate Athletic Conference championships. During those seasons, Wagner helped the Greyhounds post a combined record of 34-6.

As a senior in 2019, she was a First Team All-GLIAC and All-Midwest Region Second Team selection. In the classroom, Wagner made the Intercollegiate Women’s Lacrosse Coaches Association (IWLCA) Honor Roll that year.

During her junior campaign, Wagner earned a spot of the GLIAC All-Tournament team. As a sophomore in 2017, she set a program record with five caused turnovers in UIndy’s first-ever GLIAC Tournament victory against Findlay University.

A native of Columbus, Ohio, Wagner earned her Bachelor’s of Science degree in Sports Management in May of 2019.