2021 The Saints advanced to the AEC Semifinals again. Ending the season with a record of 5-4 with a perfect 4-0 at home.

The 2019 season marked the first year that the Saints competed in the newly-formed Atlantic East Conference, going against six other league schools including nationally-ranked Cabrini University. In the team's first year of Atlantic East competition, Reynolds led the team to a 4-2 record in conference play and earned a berth into the Atlantic East tournament. As the No. 3 seed in the tournament, Marymount hosted Wesley College in a first round game for a 17-5 victory and advanced to the conference semifinals. He coached five players to the All-Atlantic East second team on the season.

In one of the toughest leagues in the country, Reynolds took the Saints to two Capital Athletic Conference tournaments, in his third season (2008) and in 2012. Through his tenure thus far, he has racked up 66 victories with the Saints with his best year coming in 2014 when the squad went 9-8 including a five-game win streak to open the season.

In that season, he led the Saints to an ECAC postseason berth and a first-round upset over third-seeded Marywood University, 13-4. With that win, Reynolds became the winningest coach in program history.

Since taking the reins in 2006, Reynolds has steadily improved Marymount's winning percentage from season to season. The Saints' three CAC wins in 2007 are tied for the most in a season since 2001, while a 13-8 win over No. 18 Hampden-Sydney College in 2008 proves Reynolds' most notable victory to date. In 2012, Reynolds guided the Saints to their first CAC Tournament berth since 2008.

A four-year player for Marymount from 1997-00, Reynolds returned to his alma mater after five years as the head coach of nearby Yorktown High School. With the Patriots, he posted a .667 win percentage and made the regional playoffs each season. Reynolds was tabbed District and Regional Coach of the Year in 2002.

As a player for the Saints, Reynolds captained the 2000 squad that posted the programs best record at 12-6, 4-2 in the CAC, and advanced to the semifinals of the