During her nine seasons since returning to her alma mater as head coach, Conover has led the Skyhawks to 115 wins, nine Northeast-10 Conference postseason appearances, one conference title, and three NCAA tournament bids

Conover led the 2010 team to the NCAA tournament for the first time since 2007, posting a 13-4 overall record and a 10-1 mark in the NE-10. The Skyhawks claimed the second seed in the conference tournament and advanced to the NCAA quarterfinals, where they fell to eventual national champion Adelphi, and placed five players on the IWLCA and WomensLacrosse.com All-America teams. Additionally, Jaclyn Craig '10 was named the IWLCA Division II Scholar-Athlete of the Year.

The 2009 Skyhawks went 10-6 and finished second in the NE-10 behind three All-Americans, but their nine-year conference championship streak was broken with a semifinal loss to Southern New Hampshire. Michelle Kelly '09 became Conover's first nominee for NE-10 Woman of the Year.

In Conover's first season as head coach, Stonehill went 14-3 and a perfect 10-0 in NE-10 competition, extending their conference unbeaten streak to 80 games and capturing the school's tenth consecutive regular-season conference title. The team also placed four players on the IWCLA All-American squad, including the school's eighth straight NE-10 Player of the Year honoree in Michelle Kelly.

Prior to Stonehill, Conover spent four seasons as the head coach at conference rival Merrimack College, compiling a 45-20 overall record and making back-to-back NE-10 Championship appearances. Under Conover's watch, Merrimack set records for most wins in a season (12 in 2005 and 2006), produced four All-Americans, and posted their best conference record (9-1 in 2006.)

Conover enjoyed a Hall of Fame career at Stonehill, capped by an NCAA Championship in her senior season. She was named to the IWLCA All-America first team all four years, making her the first Stonehill student-athlete to become a four-time All-American in any sport. She was the NE-10 Player of the Year in 2001, 2002, and 2003, following her selection as the NE-10 Rookie of the Year in 2000. Conover was also honored as the IWLCA Attacker of the Year as a senior.